Old Forester The President's Choice is a Kentucky straight rye whisky bottled at 100 proof (50% ABV), hand-selected by Campbell P. Brown, a 5th generation member of the Brown family. This singular expression represents what the distillery considers to be among the world's finest rye whisky, aged a minimum of 24 months and personally certified by Campbell Brown's signature on each label.

Old Forester Distilling Co. carries the distinction of being America's first bottled bourbon, established in Louisville in 1870. The President's Choice represents the pinnacle of their rye whisky program, with Campbell P. Brown continuing his family's legacy of selecting exceptional barrels. This rare bottling from barrel #AB123 showcases the meticulous attention to quality that has defined Old Forester for over 150 years.

Tasting Notes

• Nose: Warm baking spices, cinnamon bark, toasted oak, vanilla cream, dried orange peel
• Palate: Bold rye spice, caramelized brown sugar, black pepper, honeyed grain, leather undertones
• Finish: Long finish with lingering spice, oak tannins, sweet vanilla fade

Product Details

Perfect For

• Collectors: Hand-selected by 5th generation family member with personal certification
• Rye Whisky Enthusiasts: Exploring premium Kentucky straight rye expressions
• Special Occasions: Celebrating moments that deserve exceptional whisky
• Neat Sipping: Full-proof character ideal for contemplative drinking

Frequently Asked Questions

What does Old Forester The President's Choice taste like?

This Kentucky straight rye delivers bold spice character with warm baking spices and cinnamon on the nose, followed by a palate of rye spice, caramelized brown sugar, and black pepper. The 100-proof strength provides full flavor intensity while maintaining balance.

Is Old Forester The President's Choice good for cocktails?

At 100 proof, this rye whisky excels in classic cocktails like Manhattans, Old Fashioneds, and Sazeracs where you want the spice character to shine through. However, given its hand-selected nature and premium positioning, many prefer to enjoy it neat or with a splash of water.

What makes this different from regular Old Forester products?

The President's Choice is hand-selected by Campbell P. Brown, a 5th generation family member, from specific barrels he deems exceptional. Each bottle is personally certified with his signature, making it a rare, limited expression compared to Old Forester's regular lineup.

How should I drink Old Forester The President's Choice?

This whisky is best enjoyed neat in a Glencairn glass to appreciate its full complexity, or with a few drops of water to open up the flavors. The 100-proof strength provides excellent flavor concentration for sipping, though it also works beautifully in premium cocktails.

Is Old Forester The President's Choice worth the price?

For rye whisky enthusiasts and collectors, the hand-selection by a 5th generation family member, personal certification, and limited availability justify the premium. The quality of Old Forester's distillation combined with careful barrel selection delivers exceptional value for a specialty bottling.

You must be 21 years of age or older to purchase this product.